The difference in one line
Notion keeps your pages in its own database and gives you an app to edit them. notdocs keeps your pages as markdown files in your git repository and gives you an app to edit them, plus an MCP server and a CLI so your coding agents edit the same files.
What follows describes Notion from its public documentation as of the date above. Notion changes often; if something here is out of date, write to hello@notdocs.dev.
Side by side
| notdocs | Notion | |
|---|---|---|
| Where content lives | Markdown files in your git repository | Notion's cloud database |
| Getting it out | It is already out: the files are the export | Export to Markdown & CSV, HTML or PDF |
| History | Git history, plus a per-document history with diffs | Page history, length depending on the plan |
| Agents | MCP server and CLI over the same operations as the app, with project tokens | API and an MCP server over the Notion workspace |
| Structured data | Typed documents with frontmatter; query blocks as boards, tables, lists, calendars and galleries | Databases with properties, relations, rollups, formulas and many views |
| Editing together | One shared session per open document, with everybody's carets; a save from an agent or another branch is three-way merged | Live co-editing with cursors |
| Sharing outside the team | By link, or published as a site on a subdomain or your own domain, every page also served as markdown | Published pages and Notion Sites |
| Apps | Web app and CLI | Web, desktop and mobile apps |
| Pricing | Flat per organization, see pricing | Per member |
Pick notdocs when
- Your docs belong next to your code. Specs, decisions, runbooks and tasks sit in the repository they describe, are reviewed in pull requests, and ship with the branch.
- Coding agents do a lot of the writing. Claude Code, Cursor and other MCP clients read and write the same files a person edits, and a merge keeps either side from overwriting the other. See Agents.
- You do not want a second source of truth. Nothing syncs between notdocs and your repository, because there is nothing to sync.
- You want to be able to leave. Uninstall the GitHub App and you still have every file. See data portability and exit.
- You are a handful of people. One flat price per organization, not per seat.
Pick Notion when
- You live in databases. Relations, rollups and formulas across many linked databases are what Notion is built for; notdocs query blocks filter, sort and group, and stop there.
- Most of your team never opens a repository. Notion needs no git account, and has desktop and mobile apps.
- You want wikis, sites and forms in one tool for a whole company, well beyond engineering and product.
Moving over
The importer turns a Notion export into typed markdown documents, keeps the folder shape, turns database rows into frontmatter and rewrites the links between pages. See Switch from Notion.